Difference between revisions of "Seismic Fire Interactions (Task 13)"
(→Scope) |
|||
| (18 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
===Purpose=== | ===Purpose=== | ||
| − | The Fire Risk Scoping Study | + | The [https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML0622/ML062260257.pdf Fire Risk Scoping Study] identified the following four seismic-fire interaction issues: |
| − | * | + | * Seismically induced fires |
| − | * | + | * Degradation of fire suppression systems and features |
| − | * | + | * Spurious actuation of suppression and/or detection systems |
| − | * | + | * Degradation of manual firefighting effectiveness |
It is recommended that a Fire PRA include a qualitative assessment of these issues. In this procedure, a recommended approach is given. | It is recommended that a Fire PRA include a qualitative assessment of these issues. In this procedure, a recommended approach is given. | ||
| − | This procedure does not provide a methodology for developing models and quantifying risk associated with fires caused by a severe seismic event. This is due to a combination of limitations in the state of the art, and the perceived low level of risk from these fires. The low risk is based on the low frequency of an earthquake that can initiate a challenging fire and degrade various plant fire protection defense-in-depth elements, and the general seismic ruggedness of the NPPs as part of their design basis. This procedure outlines a series of steps intended to verify this premise. If the verification steps outlined in this procedure do not preclude the risk significance, either a quantitative assessment or consideration of physical or procedural changes may follow. | + | This procedure does not provide a methodology for developing models and quantifying risk associated with fires caused by a severe seismic event. This is due to a combination of limitations in the state of the art, and the perceived low level of risk from these fires. The low risk is based on the low frequency of an earthquake that can initiate a challenging fire and degrade various plant fire protection defense-in-depth elements, and the general seismic ruggedness of the NPPs as part of their design basis. This procedure outlines a series of steps intended to verify this premise. If the verification steps outlined in this procedure do not preclude the risk significance, either a quantitative assessment or consideration of physical or procedural changes may follow. |
===Scope=== | ===Scope=== | ||
| − | Consistent with the recommendations of | + | Consistent with the recommendations of the [https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML0622/ML062260257.pdf Fire Risk Scoping Study] and those outlined in the [https://www.epri.com/#/pages/product/TR-100370/ EPRI FIVE] and EPRI's Fire PRA Implementation Guide [TR-105928 (no longer available on epri.com)], recommended practice in the seismic fire interactions assessment utilizes a qualitative, walkdown-based approach, rather than quantitative methods to estimated associated risk. This task provides a stand-alone study of the effects of a fire due to an earthquake. This task is not intended to develop quantitative estimates of the risk associated with seismic-fire interactions. |
| − | |||
| − | ==Related | + | ==Related Element of ASME/ANS PRA Standard== |
| + | Seismic Fire (SF) | ||
| + | ==Related EPRI 1011989 NUREG/CR-6850 Appendices== | ||
| + | None | ||
==Supplemental Guidance== | ==Supplemental Guidance== | ||
| + | Although there are no requirements to quantify seismic fire risk in Part 4 (Fire) of the ASME/ANS PRA Standard, Part 5 of the ASME/ANS PRA Standard (Seismic) does require that seismically induced initiating events caused by secondary hazards (including seismic induced internal fires) are identified, that fragilities are estimated for credible seismic induced fire sources, and that seismic induced fire scenarios are included in the seismic PRA model as necessary. [https://www.epri.com/#/pages/product/000000003002012980/?lang=en-US EPRI 3002012980] provides a methodology to treat seismically induced internal fires (and internal floods) in a seismic PRA. | ||
Latest revision as of 09:42, 3 April 2020
Contents
Task Overview
Background
This task is a qualitative approach to help identify the risk from any potential interactions between an earthquake and fire.
Purpose
The Fire Risk Scoping Study identified the following four seismic-fire interaction issues:
- Seismically induced fires
- Degradation of fire suppression systems and features
- Spurious actuation of suppression and/or detection systems
- Degradation of manual firefighting effectiveness
It is recommended that a Fire PRA include a qualitative assessment of these issues. In this procedure, a recommended approach is given.
This procedure does not provide a methodology for developing models and quantifying risk associated with fires caused by a severe seismic event. This is due to a combination of limitations in the state of the art, and the perceived low level of risk from these fires. The low risk is based on the low frequency of an earthquake that can initiate a challenging fire and degrade various plant fire protection defense-in-depth elements, and the general seismic ruggedness of the NPPs as part of their design basis. This procedure outlines a series of steps intended to verify this premise. If the verification steps outlined in this procedure do not preclude the risk significance, either a quantitative assessment or consideration of physical or procedural changes may follow.
Scope
Consistent with the recommendations of the Fire Risk Scoping Study and those outlined in the EPRI FIVE and EPRI's Fire PRA Implementation Guide [TR-105928 (no longer available on epri.com)], recommended practice in the seismic fire interactions assessment utilizes a qualitative, walkdown-based approach, rather than quantitative methods to estimated associated risk. This task provides a stand-alone study of the effects of a fire due to an earthquake. This task is not intended to develop quantitative estimates of the risk associated with seismic-fire interactions.
Related Element of ASME/ANS PRA Standard
Seismic Fire (SF)
Related EPRI 1011989 NUREG/CR-6850 Appendices
None
Supplemental Guidance
Although there are no requirements to quantify seismic fire risk in Part 4 (Fire) of the ASME/ANS PRA Standard, Part 5 of the ASME/ANS PRA Standard (Seismic) does require that seismically induced initiating events caused by secondary hazards (including seismic induced internal fires) are identified, that fragilities are estimated for credible seismic induced fire sources, and that seismic induced fire scenarios are included in the seismic PRA model as necessary. EPRI 3002012980 provides a methodology to treat seismically induced internal fires (and internal floods) in a seismic PRA.
